Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Everyone is mad about Mary Berry's pie


Following her stately, dignified exit from the Great British Bake Off, you’d have thought Mary Berry would be staying away from the headlines. But once again she’s generating more column inches than Kim K after a distinctly controversial pie recipe.

Yes: in a completely outrageous and shocking move, Mary decided to make a pie... without a base. Perhaps in an attempt to avoid a soggy bottom, Mary’s recipe for a potato, leek and cheese pie simply involves plonking a lid on the top of what is essentially a casserole.

And oh boy, did Twitter hate it.

“It is NOT a pie,” said one tweeter. “What kind of monstrosity is a pie without a base?” said another.

This isn’t the only culinary controversy Mary has been involved in recently. Only a few weeks ago the internet was once again up in arms when, in a “disgraceful” move some people definitely didn’t overreact to, Mazza added white wine and double cream to a traditional bolognese sauce.

But, according to British Pie Awards chairman Matthew O’Callaghan, there are some pretty strict rules when it comes to pies. No lattice or open top, no “only a top” – there has to be both a top and a bottom to pass muster.

And speaking to The Telegraph, O’Callaghan confirmed that Mary’s “pie” was definitely not a pie.

“That’s not a pie,” he said.

That’s us told then. 



The fry-up pie is here to bring the country together


The British public voted for their fave pies and fucked it up big time


Channel 4 getting Noel Fielding for 'Bake Off' may actually be genius


'Reverse searing' is apparently the best way to cook a steak


All the times Donald Trump has failed to condemn far-right extremists

This has gone on for some time

by Tom Victor
16 Aug 2017

Flight attendants share the 25 worst things passengers do

How many of them are you guilty of?

by Gary Ogden
16 Aug 2017

Obama's response to Charlottesville is now the most-liked tweet ever

Puts Trump's response to shame

by Emily Reynolds
16 Aug 2017

English accents have been ranked by sexiness - where is yours?

You lot up north will be happy

by Gary Ogden
16 Aug 2017

Unmissable TV shows Reddit says you have to watch before you die

From gritty dramas to kids' classics

by Emily Reynolds
15 Aug 2017

The surprising side-effect of spending just 5 minutes on Facebook

It only takes five minutes of Facebooking

by Emily Reynolds
15 Aug 2017

Uber is going to start charging you for making your driver wait

Your cab home's about to get a bit more pricey

by Carl Anka
15 Aug 2017

John Oliver takes down Trump over his comments on Charlottesville

Doing what he does best

by Gary Ogden
14 Aug 2017

This amputee has the best Tinder profile ever

You've gotta hand it to her

11 Aug 2017

Ginger emojis are finally coming!

Justice is finally being done

by Emily Reynolds
11 Aug 2017