Best Assassin Creed games, ranked

The first Assassin’s Creed game for the PS4 was a visual delight and really expanded on what you could do in an Assassin’s Creed game. Yes, there were still stealth kills but you could also sail the seas and build up your own group of pirates. This brought new blood to the franchise and showed that there was still a lot of life in the Assassin’s Creed lore.

After the second game turned Assassin’s Creed into a classic, Brotherhood showed that the quality was still there. Still in Italy, this time Ezio heads to Rome for some fantastic kills and other side quests such as building an assassin’s school and tomb raiding. It felt smaller than the other games, though, thanks to its one city setting.

This was the game that catapulted AC into the gaming big time. Gone, mostly, were the repetitive mechanics of the first game and many of the glitches were ironed out. The aminus stuff was still annoying but the Renaissance era Italy setting and Ezio as protagonist made this one of the best Assassin’s Creed games of all time.

If you want Assassin’s Creed as an RPG then this is the closest you will get. Set in Ancient Egypt, there was a real role playing aspect to the gameplay, including the ability to go on a whole host of side quests and build upon the character. It’s the most beautiful Assassin’s Creed game to play - even if it doesn’t feel like an AC game half the time.

This is the game we are hoping Assassin’s Creed: Valhalla will emulate. It’s set in Ancient Greece and has sweeping vistas, amazing gameplay and a push into a much more open style of playing (which is better than what was seen in Origins). The Exploration Mode is fantastic but the only real bugbear is that it feels like a 300 style retelling of history, taking liberties with its setting. It’s fantastic fun, though.

Given Ezio is one of the greatest computer game characters of all time, it’s a shame his story is ended on the mediocre Revelations. Yes, the action scenes are manic and it’s great to hang around with Leonardo Da Vinci again but, apart from the new zip wire functionality, the game is mired in weird mechanics and a tower defence section that is just terrible. The final scenes are a fitting send-off, though.

Syndicate managed to add something fresh to Assassin’s Creed. The idea of having two assassin’s throughout the game was refreshing but while we always wanted to see a Creed game in London, the setting just didn’t do it for us as, say, Italy. The addition of trains and more modern things like factories and the like really worked for the game, though.

The third, proper sequel to Assassin’s Creed II is a strange beast. The world is bigger and, in some respects, better but it feels hollow and empty compared to the crowded streets of Italy. There’s boats, which is fun, but the American Revolutionary War setting just doesn’t do it for us. As for those missions - they go from sublime to frustrating in seconds. It’s also the buggiest AC game since the first one.

Assassin’s Creed Unity is a next-gen Assassin’s Creed game based around the French Revolution that was packed with glitches that hindered the gameplay and graphics that were not next-gen (given they were meant to show off the console). It was released at the same time as Rogue - given Rogue was for the older generation PS3 and Xbox 360, it ended up being the better game.

Hmm, this one is never going to be high on an Assassin’s Creed best-of list. It took the naval combat from Black Flag but didn’t really build it into anything cool. Instead all that’s here is a game that’s well a bit, meh. It’s also a strange game that was launched as a last hurrah for the PS3 and Xbox 360, while Assassin’s Creed games were being made also for the next gen at the time.

There is a glimpse of brilliance in the first Assassin’s Creed but, boy, is it repetitive. You wouldn’t really think there was a big franchise in the first game, but there is enough hope in its time hopping and historical settings for it to work as a game. It really does feel like a work in progress, however. It laid the groundwork for one of the most successful franchises of all time, but it was something of a stuttering start.