ShortList is now ad free and supported by you, the users. When you buy through the links on our site we may earn a commission. Learn more

Cats reviews are in: A confusing, collective hallucination

Can it really be that terrible? Yes, it seems so.

Cats reviews are in: A confusing, collective hallucination
Holly Pyne
19 December 2019

It’s been a while since we’ve seen a film ripped to shreds in the way that Cats has. And the reviews really are brutal.

To anyone who saw the official trailer - which was released back in November - this may not be a surprise. After all, it is a story that follows the ‘Jellicle cats’, who all attend the ‘Jellicle Ball’, hoping to earn the honour of the ‘Jellicle Choice’ which will transport them into the afterlife. (Yeah, we don’t quite get it either).



Now, to be fair to the film’s Oscar-winning director Tom Hooper (The King’s Speech, Les Miserables), Empire’s John Nugent manages to find some redeemable features.


He does actually think there is some talent and craft behind it, apparently: “It is bold and visually striking, upgrading the beige setting of the stage show into a wild, gaudy, neon-lit approximation of London.”


Nugent also praises Francesca Hayward’s performance as a cat called Victoria, describing her “empathy and charisma breaking through” in a crowded ensemble.


And, they definitely did jam-pack the cast with A-listers, with Dame Judi Dench, James Corden, Idris Elba, Jason Derulo, Taylor Swift, Ian McKellen and Rebel Wilson all making an appearance.


Cats reviews are in: A confusing, collective hallucination


But it seems even a star-studded cast couldn’t save this one. The Guardian’s Peter Bradshaw offered the film adaptation of Andrew Lloyd-Webber’s show a measly 1-star rating as sometimes he simply "did not know where to look". Matt Golderg from Collider wasn't any kinder saying the film always felt "two seconds away from turning into a furry orgy in a dumpster".


The Independent’s review gave the film a generous two stars, with Clarisse Loughrey describing it as a “collective hallucination” before providing a description of Taylor Swift “shaking her cat boobs while sprinkling catnip into an enraptured crowd” (we don’t even know what to do with that image. Argh).


And yet, despite all the terrible reviews, we’re still tempted to see this confusing hairball of a mess for ourselves. It's like a disastrous car crash you can't look away from. So if, like us, you are too, Cats will be in cinemas from tomorrow (20 December).