ShortList is supported by you, our amazing readers. When you click through the links on our site and make a purchase we may earn a commission. Learn more

A weatherman on Good Morning Britain interrupted a live knife crime debate

And for good reason

A weatherman on Good Morning Britain interrupted a live knife crime debate
07 March 2019

Weather forecaster Alex Beresford interrupted a live debate on the solutions to the rise in knife crime on live TV this morning. 

Shouting from across the studio as Police Federation chair John Apter was speaking, suggesting that what we needed was more prisons, Alex felt he had to interject to voice his view that this wasn’t the answer. He later took to social media to explain his decision, watch the clip here:

“My argument, build more prisons, we need consequences” Apter says, as Beresford interrupts with:

“Prison doesn’t work, I’ve grown up in some of these communities that you’re talking about, and prison isn’t a deterrent, if you don’t change the environment it won’t change anything, and that’s the key thing. This has been happening for years OK, years, and it’s not always in the media, but it won’t change. It’s going to take several things and yes policing is one thing. All of you guys on that side, you benefitted from the environment that you’ve grown up in, you benefitted from this work environment, I’ve benefitted from it. But these boys, not all of them benefitted, and if you don’t show them something else, you won’t change it.”

Probably the most sane argument of the whole debate that’s actually looking at the causes of the rise in knife crime. There has been a spike in the coverage of the rise of violent crime in London particularly recently, with a 20 year old man being stabbed in East London yesterday and a 17 year old girl dying after a knife attack in Harold Hill, also East London, last week. 

Police and youth service cuts have been blamed for the rise, and Mayor of London Sadiq Khan said on BBC Breakfast that if the government don’t release funding for more police, then we will sadly continue to see a rise in young people dying at the hands of knife crime in the capital and around the country. He also stated that police numbers are at their lowest since 2003, and that austerity has real effects on these communities. 

After the live debate, Alex Beresford posted a video explaining why he felt so frustrated at the debate. Detailing not only his ethnicity as a mixed race man and having grown up in some of the areas most affected by knife crime, he called for a different approach, saying: “Don’t put these boys into prison if you can help it. Teach them something else, show them a different way, because often that’s when you lose young boys in the system forever.”

He also called for more representation from people from the communities affected when discussing the issue on TV, saying “the people that are being debated aren’t always represented on the programme”. He also said he’d spoken to ‘young boys, young’ about their experiences and how to tackle the issue, and that they are “not scared of going to prison. Prison is not the answer.”

Beresford’s interruption went viral with many people praising him for offering a more balanced and humane view of the situation, and looking at why this type of crime is on the rise, not just how to deal with it. A bit more than just the guy who does the weather, it seems.

(Image: Getty)