This site contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links. Learn more

Best smart displays 2019: top Alexa and Google Assistant devices tested

Alexa or Assistant? The best smart displays ranked

Best smart displays 2019: top Alexa and Google Assistant devices tested
Jon Mundy

Smart displays are pretty hot right now. The best smart displays offer a new form of media hub, and hands-free assistant for the home.

Break any smart display down into its constituent parts, and it might look rather familiar. This ostensibly fresh gadget basically combines a smart speaker with a tablet - then throws in a stand to keep it upright while you go about your business.

UPDATED: Following months of playing with the Amazon Echo Show 5, Shortlist have concluded that it is the best smart display on the market. But wait, there's more smart display news to deliver! Google has announced it is reducing the amount of audio it stores for human review, alongside new hotword sensitivity options.

The changes to its audio retention policies are set to be introduced in the coming months (after increased scrutiny surrounding how audio is stored and for how long) and will ask users to re-affirm their decision to opt-in to the program - great news for those concerned about complete strangers listening to your every conversation. The tech giant will also offer users more hotword detection options, making it less likely for the device to detect and record unintended audio, y'know, for those moments when you don't scream 'Hey Google!' across the room.

That’s not to undersell the impact this product mash-up is having, however. Being able to have all kinds of information and media at your beck and call while cooking, cleaning, and working is a powerful thing indeed.

The flexibility of interacting with that content through touch or vocal prompts makes the smart display the ultimate all-in-one home assistant. And it explains why multiple tech and internet companies are trying to gain a foothold in the smart display market.

Here are eight of the best contenders. Upvote your favourite.

\ Our Pick
Our Pick
Amazon Echo Show 5
£79.99
The Amazon Echo Show takes everything that was right with the original Echo and replaces everything that's wrong. This is a brilliant-looking, compact device that's everything you want from a smart display. The price is superb, too.
View now on Amazon

Best smart displays

Best smart displays

1. JBL Link View

£249
View now at JBL

JBL is an established provider of portable speakers and headphones, and it has stepped into the smart display market with real authority. With the JBL Link View the brand has wisely left the software smarts to Google. It focuses its attention instead on producing some of the best audio quality of any device on this list. With an 8-inch display more than holding its own on the visual side, this is a remarkably complete smart display.

4
0
Thanks for voting
Best smart displays

2. Google Nest Hub

£119.00
View now at John Lewis

The smart display formerly known as the Google Home Hub is a well-priced container for Google’s software smarts. Google Assistant responds to all manner of queries in a natural fashion, while clever integration with the peerless Google Photos can turn the device’s crisp 7-inch display into a beautiful digital picture frame. There’s no camera for video chat, unfortunately, but that will come this summer with the 10-inch Google Nest Hub Max.

5
2
Thanks for voting
Best smart displays

3. Amazon Echo Show 5

£79.99
View now on Amazon

Okay, we'll admit it - we're smitten with this device. Having had the original Echo Show for a while now, we just couldn't get on with its size or looks. The 5.5-inch display on the new Amazon Echo Show makes so much more sense, and it looks great, too. Couple it with some great privacy options and the ability to make calls through it for free and what you have is a seriously smart display.

1
1
Thanks for voting
Best smart displays

4. Amazon Echo Show

£219.99
View now at Amazon

Amazon made home assistants popular in the first place, so it shouldn’t come as too much of a surprise to learn the latest Amazon Echo Show is rather good. It packs a large 10-inch display, a smart fabric design, and of course access to the highly regarded Alexa personal assistant, not to mention Prime Video content. Twin rear-firing speakers produce decent sound, and you can initiate calls with fellow Alexa users.

0
0
Thanks for voting
Best smart displays

5. Amazon Echo Spot

£119.99
View now at Amazon

If you don’t need the widescreen features of some of the bigger smart displays on this list, the Amazon Echo Spot should prove perfect. Its compact 2.5-inch circular display is great for visualising basic Alexa queries, such as weather reports and web searches. Just don’t go asking it to play too much video content, because that’s not what it’s about. The Echo Spot is also significantly cheaper than most of the other smart displays on this list.

1
1
Thanks for voting
Best smart displays

6. Lenovo Smart Tab P10

£299.99
View now at Amazon

We’ve already mentioned that smart speakers are essentially hybrid devices, so we’re not sure what that makes the Lenovo Smart Tab P10. A deconstructed smart display, perhaps? It’s essentially a middling 10-inch Android tablet that, when plugged into the supplied speaker dock, becomes an Alexa-powered smart display. There’s a degree of flexibility here its rivals can’t match, though its smart speaker functionality isn’t quite as polished or intuitive as the more focused alternatives.

1
1
Thanks for voting
Best smart displays

7. LG ThinQ WK9

$249.99
View now at LG

We’d be tempted to describe the LG ThinQ WK9 as the runt of the initial Google smart display litter, if only for its ugly looks and current US-only availability. But there’s nothing puny about the WK9’s boombox-like proportions. Twin 20W speakers flank an 8-inch touchscreen. Yep, this is all about the audio, with the kind of thumpingly bassy output you’d normally expect of a dedicated sound system. This one is for the party'ers.

1
1
Thanks for voting
Best smart displays

8. Facebook Portal

£169
View now at Facebook

The Facebook Portal family isn’t available outside of the US just yet, but that’s all set to change later this year. With 15.6-inch and 10.1-inch options, the Portal could have been perfect for those who wanted a fuller media experience, but video streaming compatibility is rather limited. The main focus here is on placing Facebook Messenger video calls, supported by superior camera and mic tech, and software that cleverly tracks the caller around the room.

0
2
Thanks for voting

SOMETHING MISSING FROM OUR SHORTLIST?

Tell us about it, and if enough people agree we'll add it in.