Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

The London Tube Strike Actually Benefited The Economy

tubestrike1.jpg

As Boris Johnson never tires of telling us, when the tube workers strike, they inconvenience people and cost the economy millions of pounds of lost income. But that may not actually be true. How strange for Boris. He's never normally wrong is he? Next they'll be telling us they got a bad deal for the Olympic Stadium.

A fascinating analysis of the London Tube strike in February 2014, by researchers from the Universities of Cambridge and Oxford, has found that they actually produced a net economic benefit, as a result of commuters being forced to experiment with a different route - and then finding that the new route was actually an improvement.

The researchers examined 20 days of anonymised Oyster card data, containing over 200 million data points, to observe how individual journeys were altered. As the 2014 strike was only partial, it enabled the research team to directly compare those affected to those not affected - and then to see whether people chose to return to their previous route in the following days, or whether they switched to their new one.

Oyster Card

Amazingly one in 20 people found a better route and then stuck to it - with commuters who had previously traveled on one of the slower lines (for example, the District line) more likely to change. By then performing a cost-benefit analysis, researchers found that the amount of saved time, over the long term, outweighed the combined time lost by other commuters during the course of the one-day strike. The idea of 'forced' innovation, when people are nudged to change a routine that is actually sub-optimal, bringing long-term benefit, is known in economics as the Porter hypothesis.

Co-author Dr Ferninand Rauch, from Oxford’s Department of Economics, added: “One of the things we’re looking at is whether consumers usually make the best decision, but it’s never been empirically tested using a large consumer dataset such as this one. Our findings illustrate that people might get stuck with suboptimal decisions because they don’t experiment enough.”

Another co-author Dr Tim Willems, also from Oxford’s Department of Economics, said: “Given that a significant fraction of commuters on the London underground failed to find their optimal route until they were forced to experiment, perhaps we should not be too frustrated that we can’t always get what we want, or that others sometimes take decisions for us. If we behave anything like London commuters and experiment too little, hitting such constraints may very well be to our long-term advantage.” 

So, next time you're cursing the unions, just remember: they're actually doing us all a big favour. Shake their hand when you see them.

(Image: Rex)

Related

1.jpg

Stevie Wonder doing carpool karaoke is the most uplifting video you’ll

boris1.jpg

The Night Tube Isn't Going to Start Until March 2016

3ksx3.jpg

14 Signs That Show The Tube Has A Sense Of Humour Afterall

Comments

More

You can now buy 'luxury iceberg water' for £80

Water joke

by Dave Fawbert
17 Feb 2017

There is an eighth continent that you had no idea existed

Move over Australasia, there's a new kid in town

17 Feb 2017

Tony Blair declares "mission" to get UK to "rise up" against Brexit

Former PM claims people voted "without knowledge of the true terms of Brexit"

by Joe Ellison
17 Feb 2017

The most batshit crazy moments from Trump's latest press conference

"War with Russia would be a nuclear holocaust like no other"

by Emily Badiozzaman
17 Feb 2017

People are angry about this video of a woman talking to cheating ex

The brutal reality of #HurtBae is uniting the internet in outrage

by Dave Fawbert
16 Feb 2017

14-year-old gives chocolates to all 537 girls in his school

This guy. This guy. We should all be this guy

by Dave Fawbert
16 Feb 2017

Bulletproof glass wall to be built around base of Eiffel Tower

In an effort to protect the fragile tower from attacks

by Emily Badiozzaman
16 Feb 2017

Danny Wallace: My incredibly secret action film role

Another life lesson from our award-winning columnist

15 Feb 2017

The best bracing British train journeys

Rail guru Mark Smith recommends his favourite wintry routes

15 Feb 2017

These are officially the coolest places to visit in Europe

Time to dust off that EHIC card

15 Feb 2017