Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

The first-ever green card has been awarded in a football match

refereegreencard.jpg

History was made this weekend in a Serie B match between Virtus Entella and Vicenza, when a player received the game's first-ever green card.

But what do you have to do to earn a green card we hear you ask? Is it like hockey - a warning card before a yellow card? Or a sin bin trial?

No - it's actually awarded for instances of fair play on the pitch. Vicenza striker Cristian Galano was the first recipient of the award after admitting that no defenders had touched his shot, after the referee, Marco Mainardi, incorrectly awarded a corner. The decision was then changed to be a goal kick.

The player shown the most cards over the season will receive an award, although we have no idea what that might be. Perhaps some premium bonds or something.

Serie B president Andrea Abodi explained that the initiative is designed to try and help the reputation of the Italian leagues, following the match-fixing scandal that erupted at the start of the season.

“It’s a symbolic award,” said Abodi. “It could be something very simple. The important thing is to recognise it when a professional does something exemplary."

A Serie B spokesman added, "We think that football needs positive messages. This sport is too often embroiled in controversy that drives people away from the stadiums.”

So far, so commendable. But is this actually something we want to catch on?

West Ham's Paolo di Canio famously won a FIFA Fair Play award after catching the ball instead of shooting, when Everton goalkeeper Paul Gerrard was lying stricken on the floor during a match in 2000.

Again, a nice thing to do when someone was potentially hurt. We're all for that sort of thing.

But do we really want our players being honest over decisions such as corners and free-kicks? I mean, it's literally just not cricket is it?

The confrontational aspect of football is one of its greatest strengths.

Consider this:

It's just the most dastardly, evil thing isn't it? Inexcusable. Awful. And yet, who can honestly say that they don't have a tiny piece of admiration for just how devilish it was? And the millions watching back in Uruguay probably didn't care either (nb. the best bit is the 'who, me?' gesture when he is shown the red card).

And even if you hate him, isn't it part of the fun of football, to have someone to really hate? That pantomime villain who we can all demonise? What would we talk about if every single decision was correct? Goalline technology - yes, that's an unarguable fact, whether a ball has, or has not, crossed a line, but there's so much grey area in football, and many would argue that it's there that all the fun lies: the arguments; the controversy; the injustice; the stories.

Furthermore, we already have situations where Europa League spots can be awarded for teams with the best fair play record - it's only logical that, if a green card was introduced into football, then prized competition spots might be given away on the basis of these cards. Imagine a last game of the season where two teams play each other, both with similar amounts of green cards and try to out-nice each other. "It's your corner, honestly." "No, please, it really isn't, it's definitely your goal kick." It would be nauseating to watch.

While this might be an extreme example, it does beg the question: could there be such a thing as too much honesty in football?

It's grubby, but perhaps that's the way we really like it.

Related

pele.jpg

Football's wonderkids that never made it

fifa.jpg

The new FIFA president wants to ruin the World Cup

allardyce.jpg

Sam Allardyce was foolish but he shouldn’t have been sacked

More

Sergio Ramos just mercilessly destroyed Lionel Messi

Best in the world? Go fetch mate

by Carl Anka
17 Aug 2017

The 25 best forgotten Premier League goals of all time

Sorry, but these are all better than that Bergkamp goal

by Tom Victor
15 Aug 2017

The Premier League could make the transfer change we've all been after

Fi-na-lly

by Tom Victor
15 Aug 2017

This ref-cam video from Real Madrid's recent game is very, very cool

Shows just how impossible their job is

by Tom Victor
14 Aug 2017

Mo Farah is ditching his name for his new career as a marathon runner

Retiring from track and retiring his name

by Tom Victor
14 Aug 2017

The 50 greatest José Mourinho quotes

Not short of self-confidence

by Tom Victor
11 Aug 2017

Which new Premier League signings will flop this season?

Who'll be a hit and who will be shit?

by Sam Diss
11 Aug 2017

Brutally honest stereotypes about every Premier League team's fans

Who are ya? Who are ya? Who are ya?

by Sam Diss
10 Aug 2017

You have to watch this astonishing 15-second own goal

The other team doesn't even touch the ball

by Tom Victor
10 Aug 2017

We got Michael Owen to review the few movies he’s ever finished

"Didn’t like Rocky I, it’s rubbish"

by Alex Christian
10 Aug 2017