TV

12 unbelievable updates to the Making a Murderer case that you need to know about

Posted by
Chris Sayer
Published
10 unbelievable updates to the Making a Murderer case that you need to know about 10

The continued investigation in the murder of Teresa Halbach has moved on considerably since Netflix’s Making A Murderer first aired in 2015. Here’s what you should know before you watch season two

The entire world may have seen all ten episodes of Netflix’s smash documentary Making a Murderer, but that’s not stopped everyone from continuing to talk about it or becoming obsessed with true crime.

Thankfully, we’re not short of new case information and updates to digest and add into our never-ending conversations. That’s due, in part to convicted murderer Steven Avery’s new lawyer Kathleen Zellner being brought in to replace original series hero Jerry Buting. As we’ve seen between series Zellner is not afraid to gift avid fans and amateur sleuths with slices of tasty, often cryptic new evidence through her Twitter feed.

Unsurprisingly didn’t take long for filmmakers to pick the case back up and interview Avery for ‘future episodes’, and we now have confirmation that a second season of the show will arrive on Netflix on October 19.

With plenty of evidence that appears to have been completely missed the first time around, we’ll definitely be glued to our screens all over again when season two rolls around.

Here are 12 important things that have happened in Avery’s case since Making A Murderer first hit our screens…

The Secret Brother

making-a-murderer

The name Earl Avery ring any bells? No, probably not, and for good reason – Steven’s younger brother was notably absent from the Making A Murderer documentary. Earl’s name only became entwined in the case when a 2009 court filing was unearthed, in which Steven claimed his brothers had motive to kill Teresa Halbach for money, a share of the family business and his former girlfriend. This is a statement that Steven went on to apologise for.

That said, it took Earl until 2016 to finally come forward with a witness account that could throw the Manitowoc Police Department’s timeline into the shredder.

Speaking about the night Halbach was murdered, Earl claimed her car was not even on their land before police found it: “We drove right through there, where that car was supposed to be and it wasn’t there. That night of the 31st, we were rabbit hunting,” he told Access Hollywood in his first ever interview. He even claimed he told the police this, but they “didn’t say nothing about it.”

The Reddit Spot

10 unbelievable updates to the Making a Murderer case that you need to know about 11

Ah, the ‘planted’ key

Depending on what side of the innocent/guilty fence you fall on, the car key found under dodgy circumstances by investigators either damns Avery or proves the Manitowoc’s deep-set corruption. Either way, Reddit users think they’ve spotted something far more important when it comes to that piece of evidence.

They believe that the image above, one used repeatedly through the documentary, shows Halbach’s RAV4 key was on an assorted ring of keys, and not on its own, as the police found it. If that’s the case, somebody must have removed it from the rest of her keys after her death and before dropping it in that corner of the trailer. Avery? The police? Somebody else? Who knows…

The Cell Phone Tower Records

10 unbelievable updates to the Making a Murderer case that you need to know about 12

Alright, this is the bit that really piqued the attention of the Making a Murderer armchair detectives. Zellner isn’t shy when it comes to dropping snippets of newly-discovered intelligence over on her Twitter account, but the revelation that Halbach MUST have left Avery’s property alive is the biggest eye-opener yet.

If her uncovered cell phone tower records check out, she claims to be able to document the victim’s route as she leaves the presence of Avery… alive. Zellner told Newsweek: “She goes back the same way she came, she’s 12 miles from the property on the last ping…It’s really hard to figure out how in the world the defense did not seize on this. It would have created reasonable doubt.”

The Frightened Juror

10 unbelievable updates to the Making a Murderer case that you need to know about 14

Filmmakers Laura Ricciardi and Moira Demos, the two who made Making a Murderer, hit NBC’s Today show back in January 2016 and delivered a hammer blow to the legitimacy of Avery’s court proceedings. There, they revealed that an unnamed juror had in fact believed the suspect to be innocent (or more accurately ‘not proven guilty’), but gave a guilty verdict in fear of their own safety. 

“They told us really that they were afraid that if they held out for a mistrial that it would be easy to identify which juror had done that and that they were fearful for their own safety,” Demos said.

The ‘Unidentified’ Bones

making-a-murderer

Pop your eyeballs back into your skull – you read that correctly. Campaigners for Avery’s freedom believe that none of the protocols surrounding the testing of the remains found on Avery’s land were followed, and evidence was logged so poorly that it could have easily been tampered with. They even go so far as to question whether the FBI tested the bones at all, given the bone evidence in court was listed as ‘charred material’ and never properly proven to share the DNA of Halbach. 

Lynne Blanchard from ‘Stop Wrongful Convictions’ says, “Why weren’t protocols followed? No coroner, forensic anthropologist, arson investigator of photographer was called to the scene when the evidence was discovered… until after the evidence was shovelled up and taken to the sheriff’s office. Something’s wrong and it becomes difficult to accept this evidence as presented.”

The New Suspect

10 unbelievable updates to the Making a Murderer case that you need to know about 15

We all have our own theories as to who actually killed Halbach, not least Avery’s own new lawyer. Keeping her cards very close to her chest so as not to “scare him off”, Kathleen Zellner boldly told Newsweek, when asked about potential suspects, “We have a couple. I’d say there’s one, leading the pack by a lot.” Zellner has openly questioned why Avery’s previous legal team failed to look into other potential perpetrators in their investigations – a path that she is dead-set on treading.      

The Dodgy Death Certificate

10 unbelievable updates to the Making a Murderer case that you need to know about 16

We’ll cut to the case here: this official document is one heck of a mess as we reported at the time.

At a glance, you can instantly see that the word ‘Undetermined’ is simply crossed out under ‘Cause of death’ before being seeing it confirmed as homicide, as well as noting that a body hasn’t been located even though in another part of the paper it states an autopsy has been completed. For many, this goes some way to prove that the authorities were rushing through an Avery conviction and that evidence was handled extremely incompetently. Worth questioning why such an official document could be so epicly bungled, no? 

The New Tests

making-a-murderer

A lot has changed since Avery’s conviction back in 2007, including the way in which convictions can be made, or indeed overturned. 

Zellner has taken many samples from her client since coming onto the case, and is looking to use “advanced luminol testing” to exonerate him. In simple chat, these tests aim to detect blood that can’t be seen by eye. Quite what she’s hoping to prove, we’re as yet unsure, but sounds like she has a plan…

The British CSI Expert’s Questions

Over to Sussex now, where CSI expert Chris Gee thinks he’s asked one question that nobody else has. 

In a four-part YouTube video series looking into the case, he determines that even though Avery’s blood was found near the ignition of Halbach’s Toyota, it doesn’t actually place him there – the possibility arises that somebody with Avery’s blood on them was. Confused? Watch it for yourself here. Note the excellent placement of the CSI mug. 

The Petition to the White House

making-a-murderer

It takes a huge 100,000 signatures for The White House to become obliged to consider a petition made on the government’s We The People website. Thanks to 129,886 people signing the dotted line, that’s exactly what happened. 

However, things didn’t exactly go to plan for all those calling for Avery and his nephew Brendan Dassey’s freedom. Why? Because it’s only able to grant pardons for crimes committed against the USA. Ten outta ten for effort though, eh?

The prosecutor’s response

making-a-murderer

Anyone familiar with the first run of Making a Murderer will likely have strong opinions about Ken Kratz, the prosecutor in Avery’s case who, until recently, served as District Attorney for Calumet County in Wisconsin. Kratz resigned from his post in 2010, in the aftermath of a sexting scandal unrelated to the events covered in the documentary.

In an interview ahead of the release of his book Avery: The Case Against Steven Avery and What ‘Making a Murderer’ Gets Wrong, Kratz claimed the filmmakers “distorted and misrepresented the case.

“They knew they had a narrative to present and they picked and chose certain clips, they shuffled things around to make it look sketchy and they omitted a lot of the relevant evidence,” he argued.

Brendan Dassey’s fate has been up in the air… a lot

making-a-murderer

Making a Murderer wasn’t just about the conviction of Steven Avery, of course - Brendan Dassey was also sent down for his alleged part in the crimes, and viewers of the show expressed concern at his confession having been coerced.

In 2016, magistrate judge William Duffin ordered for the release of Dassey, a teenager at the time of his imprisonment, on the grounds that Duffin found Dassey’s confession to have been coerced. However, that was not the end of things.

The appeals court blocked that initial release, only for a three-judge panel to support the decision to overturn. However, after that, there was a further appeal which resulted in 4-3 vote ruling that Dassey’s confession had in fact been obtained properly. Dassey’s lawyers have filed a further petition in the months since, but that was denied and he remains behind bars.

Topics

Share this article

Author

Chris Sayer

Chris Sayer is a freelance journalist and editor based in London. Chris has interviewed some of the biggest names in entertainment and travelled the world doing an all manner of adventures for lots of brilliant magazines. He writes for Shortlist about booze but would probably prefer we let him write about fishing instead. Follow Chris on Twitter: @ChrisSayer00

Recommended by Chris Sayer

  • TV

    'Making a Murderer' season 2 is back next month - here's everything you need to know

    Let's get some homework done, eh?

    Posted by
    Shortlist Team
    Published
  • TV

    'Making a Murderer': Stunning development implicates a new suspect

    Could this be the turning point for Steven's quest for freedom?

    Posted by
    Harvey Day
    Published
  • TV

    ‘Making a Murderer’ lawyer attacks police sergeant on Twitter and accuses him of planting evidence

    He clearly is still very angry about the Steven Avery case

    Posted by
    Harvey Day
    Published
  • TV

    This serial killer thriller is going to be your next Netflix obsession

    It's out just before 'Stranger Things'

    Posted by
    Gary Ogden
    Published
  • TV

    British CSI finds some very convincing Making A Murderer evidence

    He's got some questions about the Avery case...

    Published
  • News

    There's been a big development in the Making A Murderer case

    There's been a big development in the Making A Murderer case

    Posted by
    Joe Ellison
    Published
  • News

    There's been a huge breakthrough in the Making a Murderer case

    Independent testing of key evidence can now begin

    Posted by
    Chris Sayer
    Published
  • Entertainment

    New Making a Murderer data may prove Halbach left Avery’s home alive

    New Making a Murderer evidence could prove Teresa Halbach left Avery’s property alive

    Posted by
    Chris Sayer
    Published
  • News

    Viewers spot new Making a Murder evidence that changes everything

    Viewers spot crucial new Making a Murderer evidence that could change everything

    Posted by
    Nick Pope
    Published

Other people read

More from TV

More from Chris Sayer