Why 'Better Call Saul’ is way better than ‘Breaking Bad’ according to Guillermo del Toro

Posted by
Tom Victor

As the fourth season of Better Call Saul gathers pace, the Breaking Bad spin-off is already closing in on the run-time of its predecessor.

‘Felina’, the final Breaking Bad episode, was the 62nd overall. Better Call Saul is already more than halfway there, and will hit number 40 at the end of the current run on 8 October. 

On top of all that both series are regularly featured in lists of the best TV shows ever made. 

Comparisons between the shows are inevitable, considering the presence of common characters such as Saul Goodman, Mike Ehrmantraut and Gus Fring not to mention other Breaking Bad crossover rumours, while co-creator Vince Gilligan has hinted the prequel will move towards the events of the original show

You may have strong opinions on which of the shows is ‘better,’ but you’re not the only one – Oscar-winning director Guillermo Del Toro has had his say, and he believes Better Call Saul has overtaken Breaking Bad due at least in part to the way it handles the “moral downfall” of its main character.


“I like it even more than BB, not to be a contrarian but because the evident stakes seem smaller but the moral downfall strike me as deeper, more poignant,” the director of The Shape of Water tweeted.

“With Walter White (who turns Black) you were tracking a massive downfall/transformation. BCS takes you by the hand as Jimmy becomes Saul Goodman (No Good in him) in small painful tumbles.”

Explaining that “Kim is the key,” he adds that “Even in his relationship with Chuck, Jimmy was an enabler, he kind of loved seeing Chuck diminished. Both brothers wanted to see the other “down”. Beautifully laid out.”

Here’s why Guillermo del Toro thinks ‘Better Call Saul’ is better than ‘Breaking Bad’

It is not the first time Del Toro has praised Better Call Saul, with the director reserving specific praise for Gilligan and his team at the close of season two.

Bob Odenkirk, who plays Jimmy McGill/Saul Goodman across the fictional universe, admitted he initially considered the spin-off a huge risk. He also spoke of his fears for the direction his character was taking, saying “I’m having to confront the fact that he is becoming Saul, and I don’t like Saul.”

The third season of Better Call Saul was considered the second-best Netflix original show of 2017 by critics, and there’s every chance the fourth season sees it climb one place higher in 2018.

Get ShortList Daily straight to your inbox for free

(Images: Netflix/Getty)


Which show is better - 'Breaking Bad' or 'Better Call Saul'?


Share this article


Recommended by Tom Victor

  • Quizzes

    Only a true 'Breaking Bad' fan can get more than 15/20 in this quiz

    Five seasons. 20 Characters. You do the meth

    Posted by
    Tom Victor
  • TV

    "I still have the jacket I died in": Giancarlo Esposito talks Gus Fring and 'Breaking Bad'

    Revealing the secrets of playing the ultimate drug dealing kingpin

    Posted by
    Tom Ellen
  • TV

    'Breaking Bad' creator finally reveals the answer to the show's grossest question

    10 years later, we have the answer

    Posted by
    Alex Finnis
  • Films

    How ‘The Shape of Water’ subtly became the queer, race-aware, #MeToo masterpiece of 2018

    This movie will have you bawling in the cinema

    Posted by
    Harvey Day
  • TV

    Judd Apatow reveals how he nearly stopped Bryan Cranston playing Walter White in 'Breaking Bad'

    Things could easily have been very different

    Posted by
    Dave Fawbert

Other people read

More from TV

More from Tom Victor