Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

The Most Overrated And Underrated Films

overrated1.jpg
overrated2.jpg
overrated3.jpg

Some battles are as old as time itself. Light vs dark. Cats vs dogs. Critics vs fans.

Ben Moore was so intrigued by this last standoff that he turned his considerable data analysis skills to charting the most overrated (loved by critics, rejected by the massses) and underrated (you get the idea) films of all time.

To carry out his investigation, Moore turned to the critical aggregator Rotten Tomatoes - the disputed king of cumulative review scores. Building a sample of films (around 2,600), Moore grabbed the data for the critics' scores and public scores. The most overrated and underrated were thus easily identifiable after plugging the data into the following graph (click to enlarge):

On the whole, both sides agree on the majority of films. The results for the most underrated were as follows:

If you were wondering what Facing the Giants was about (we were), it's an Evangelical Christian film that centres around an American football team. Critics also appear to dislike lowbrow comedies (Diary of a Mad Black Woman, Grandma’s boy) and felt equally betrayed as we did over the handling of the Bad Boys sequel.

The most overrated were as follows:

In short, the public don't seem to warm to kid's films (or Hugh Grant) as much as the critics do.

To see the complete results of Moore's amazing research, check out the following detailed graph. We're off to write an aggressive comment on the Facebook fan page of Bad Boys II.

(Images: Benjamin Moore; Rex)

Related

hendersons.jpg

12 films to remind you of your childhood on Netflix

615x330-in-del-toro-byrne-ctk32062.jpg

Bad Netflix reviews for great movies

alone-in-the-dark.jpg

Good Netflix reviews for bad movies

chocolate-factory.jpg

Actors who hated remakes of their movies

hero1.jpg

Bleak Movies Colouring Book

evans.jpg

Gareth Evans On 7 Cult Martial Arts Films

Comments

More

Why Tom Hardy is the man the world needs right now

Politicians are lying to us. Brexit is dividing us. Donald Trump may be about to nuke us. But don’t worry, we’ve found a saviour

by Joe Ellison
24 Feb 2017

New Horror movie about racism is 100% on Rotten Tomatoes

Rave reviews all round

by Matt Tate
24 Feb 2017

Netflix picks up Martin Scorsese's 'The Irishman'

Production is scheduled to begin next year

22 Feb 2017

'Star Wars' release the first cast photo from the Han Solo spin-off

You can't have too much Chewie

by Matt Tate
22 Feb 2017

QUIZ: How well do you know Hugh Jackman’s Wolverine?

As everyone’s favourite foul-mouthed mutant returns to screens in Logan, we put your knowledge to the test

21 Feb 2017

Guillermo Del Toro ends the speculation about Hellboy 3

Big Red fans, it's not good news

21 Feb 2017

The ShortList Alternative Oscars

The only awards that really matter

by Gary Ogden
20 Feb 2017

Is Love Actually actually shit or brilliant?

Two writers argue their case for the divisive 2003 rom-com

16 Feb 2017

The totally excellent 19 facts you never knew about Wayne’s World

No way? Way.

by Keyan Milanian
16 Feb 2017

Details of the Star Wars: The Last Jedi teaser trailer 'leaked'

If it's true, Star Wars fans are in for a treat

14 Feb 2017