Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Great cast, shame about the movie


While many of us are still more easily swayed by a talented director or a juicy subject matter, many are still easily swayed by star power. That familiarity of a well-known actor up on screen proving to be a key reason why some films fly and others don't.

But a great cast does not always a great movie make. We've assembled a list of the most impressive casts heading up the most disappointing movies. The rules? Each film needs at least five great actors and a Rotten Tomatoes rating of under 50%. Consider this a warning.

(Images: All Star)

10. Bobby

Starring: Anthony Hopkins, Helen Hunt, Laurence Fishburne, William H Macy, Martin Sheen, Demi Moore, Sharon Stone, Elijah Wood, Harry Belafonte and Shia LaBeouf

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 46%

The story of Robert F Kennedy's assassination is an undeniably fascinating tale. Yet, director Emilio Estevez (yes, really) chose to tell it via the fictionalised accounts of a large ensemble cast of characters, all of whom were defined by just one characteristic: interminable dullness. And this is despite the impressive credentials of the cast, which was ultimately a little bit too large and star-studded to provide any depth.

What the critics said: "It makes you wish you were watching a biopic of Robert Kennedy instead" Independent on Sunday


9. Rules of Engagement

Starring: Samuel L Jackson, Tommy Lee Jones, Ben Kingsley, Guy Pearce and Philip Baker Hall

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 36%

Despite coming from legendary director William Friedkin (The French Connection) and Oscar-winning screenwriter Stephen Gaghan (Traffic), this legal thriller never really reached the heights it should have. Denying us the on-screen drama we'd hoped from the awards-friendly cast (seven Oscar nominations and two wins between them), it was surprisingly stale and also labelled "probably the most racist film ever made against Arabs by Hollywood" by The American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee. Which is never a good thing.

What the critics said: "A broad and obvious approach to ambiguous material that's virtually all plot mechanics with little nuance or characterization" Variety


8. Running With Scissors

Starring: Annette Bening, Alex Baldwin, Brian Cox, Evan Rachel Wood, Jill Clayburgh, Joseph Fiennes, Patrick Wilson and Gwyneth Paltrow

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 30%

This one seemed to have a lot going for it. Based on an acclaimed novel, centred around the Oscar-friendly staple of the dysfunctional family, a true story, that cast...but it didn't really take off. Admittedly, Annette Bening scored herself a Golden Globe nomination for Best Actress in a Musical or Comedy but in a category that's previously features Angelina Jolie in The Tourist, it's faint praise. In adapting a novel that was already far-fetched, the film drifted into screechy theatrics.

What the critics said: "Maybe all this really happened, but I didn't believe a second of it as portrayed" Chicago Reader


7. Amelia

Starring: Hilary Swank, Richard Gere, Ewan McGregor, Christopher Eccleston and Mia Wasikowska

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 21%

Another example of a fascinating historical figure getting a disappointingly pedestrian big screen treatment in this failed attempt to tell the story of Amelia Earhart. In what was a rather plain attempt to score another Oscar, Hilary Swank found herself at the centre of a commercial and critical flop. We still wait patiently for another more finely tuned Earhart biopic.

What the critics said: "Hilary Swank is forced to deliver dialogue that sounds as if it was written in Chinese and then translated into English by a computer" The Times


6. G-Force

Starring: Bill Nighy, Penelope Cruz, Zach Galifianakis, Steve Buscemi, Nicolas Cage and Sam Rockwell

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 21%

In what the actors involved would surely refer to as "a movie my kids can finally watch", Jerry Bruckheimer decided that a 3D adventure about talking guinea pigs would be a surefire winner. To be fair to him, the box office was strong and the film doubled its budget worldwide. But the reviews were scathing and only the actors providing voices were able to hide. Not so fast, Nighy.

What the critics said: "G-Force is an aggressively stupid entry in the family-adventure genre from Jerry Bruckheimer" - Washington Post


5. Valentine's Day

Starring: Jamie Foxx, Julia Roberts, Bradley Cooper, Emma Roberts, Kathy Bates, Shirley MacLaine and Anne Hathaway

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 18%

After He's Just Not That Into You proved to be commercially successful and an easy way for A-Listers to do a small amount of work yet get handsome rewards, Valentine's Day became a no-brainer. Coincidentally, it also had no brains. Squandering a huge cast, it was patronisingly aimed at a seemingly undemanding female audience and depressingly scored a record-breaking opening weekend for a romantic comedy. New Year's Eve soon followed, with diminishing returns...

What the critics said: "It's got a cold, shiny cash register right where its heart should be" Time Out


4. Alexander

Starring: Colin Farrell, Anthony Hopkins, Angelina Jolie, Christopher Plummer, Rosario Dawson and Jared Leto

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 16%

Choosing to tell the story of a fascinating historical figure with the help of an A-List cast, it seemed as if Oliver Stone was onto a surefire winner with Alexander. Except that he really really wasn't. The film was loathed and despite two different cuts released on DVD (with one more still to come), no one's mind was remotely changed.

What the critics said: "Not just a bad movie but a bad movie of truly epic proportions" Toronto Star


3. Jonah Hex

Starring: Josh Brolin, John Malkovich, Michael Fassbender, Michael Shannon and Aidan Quinn

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 12%

Hoping to create yet another successful DC Comics adaptation, Warner Bros figured that dark western Jonah Hex would be a smart cinematic move. But following in the footsteps of Wild Wild West and proving to be another cautionary tale pre-Cowboys & Aliens, the final film showed that blockbuster westerns just don't work. It flopped at the box office and with critics, making it a rare turkey for Michael Fassbender.

What the critics said: "Director Jimmy Hayward fails to establish a viable reason for this movie to exist" Rolling Stone


2. All The King's Men

Starring: Sean Penn, Jude Law, Anthony Hopkins, Kate Winslet, Mark Ruffalo, Patricia Clarkson and James Gandolfini

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 11%

Before its release, this 40s-set political drama was seen to be a major awards contender, due largely to its impressive cast (four Oscars and 15 nominations between them). But after being pushed back a year, the rumour mill started. After it premiered at Toronto, reviews were universally negative and the film bombed at the box office with just a $9 million from a $55 million budget.

What the critics said: "Overstuffed and fatally miscast, All the King's Men never comes to life" Variety


1. Movie 43

Starring: Kate Winslet, Hugh Jackman, Richard Gere, Naomi Watts, Emma Stone, Halle Berry, Chloe Grace Moretz, Uma Thurman, Liev Schreiber, Justin Long, Terrence Howard and Dennis Quaid

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 4%

If you need just one example of how stuffing a bad film with A-Listers doesn't stop it from still being a bad film, then here it is. The poster boasted of "the biggest cast ever assembled" yet most of them actively avoided doing any publicity for the critically loathed comedy. Richard Gere tried to pull out while Colin Farrell managed to successfully remove himself from the project. Also worth noting that Julianne Moore starred in an excised sketch. So shame on her too.

What the critics said: "Deadly dull, unfunny, offensive, and stultifyingly clumsy" New Yorker


28 weeks later.jpg

Great scene, shame about the rest of the film


Nice poster, shame about the film


Great soundtrack, shame about the movie



Why Rocky is the most important film about masculinity ever made

As the film turns 40, here's why the boxing saga is so much more than an underdog story

by Tom Fordy
01 Dec 2016

We asked men to tell us which movies make them cry

...and then we definitively ranked their pain

by Sam Diss
30 Nov 2016

Watch newly released trailer for Star Wars: Rogue One

by Joe Ellison
28 Nov 2016

Adam Driver and Andrew Garfield spent a week in silence in Wales

Solid dedication to a film's title

by Emily Badiozzaman
25 Nov 2016

Watch boxing drama Bleed For This for FREE with ShortList Film Club

Another, erm, knockout offer from our Film Club

by Tom Fordy
23 Nov 2016

Danny Boyle tells us what to expect from Trainspotting 2

Danny Boyle on why he’s brought back four icons for T2: Trainspotting

23 Nov 2016

Watch the trailer for Martin Scorsese's epic 'Silence'

30 years in the making: here's your first look

by Dave Fawbert
23 Nov 2016

Watch the full trailer for Netflix's Barack Obama biopic

From Beta House to The White House

by Joe Ellison
22 Nov 2016

20 best thrillers to watch on Netflix

How many of these nerve-janglers have you seen?

by Tom Fordy
18 Nov 2016

Ryan Reynolds discusses his nervous breakdown

"I literally had the shakes."

17 Nov 2016