Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

Critics who've hated this year's Oscar nominees

captain-phillips.jpg
bruce-dern-nebraska.jpg
philomena.jpg
12-years-a-slave.jpg
615x330-gravity-3.jpg

There's just no pleasing some people. This Sunday's Oscar line-up boasts the most appealing set of films we've seen for years, from Steve McQueen's powerful slavery drama 12 Years A Slave to Spike Jonze's bittersweet romance Her. For once, it's an embarrassment of riches.

But not everyone agrees. We've taken a look at the critics who've gone against the grain for the nine Best Picture nominees and shared their distaste below. You might notice one name who crops up quite a lot...

Gravity

Rotten Tomatoes rating:97%

"Deadly boring...these characters may be, in the physical sense, people—but Joss Whedon’s Avengers have more psychological density and idiosyncrasy, more unruly humanity." Richard Brody, The New Yorker

"This is hardly even a film; it’s more like the prologue of another science fiction film laboriously stretched out to feature length, or the intro to the film’s subsequent theme park ride." Jake Cole, Movie Mezzanine

"Cuaron plays with philosophy in a shallow, juvenile way, the same as he misuses technology" Armond White, CityArts

____________________________________________________________

12 Years A Slave

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 96%

"It's a picture that stays more than a few safe steps away from anything so dangerous as raw feeling" Stephanie Zacharek, Village Voice

"You want people to understand the truth? Explore it. Don’t make it feel like a trip to the dentist’s office. There’s more to a hard truth than “hard to watch.” Vince Mancini, Film Drunk

"The only conversation this film inspires would contain howls of discomfort."Armond White, CityArts

____________________________________________________________

Dallas Buyers Club

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 94%

"...obnoxious hokum, an important story so distilled and stripped of its essence that by the end, it's not about AIDS and the fight for new drugs at all." Will Leitch, Deadspin

"...more often than not it impulsively switches gear into prestige-picture mode, goading the audience into a highly codified and instructed path of emotions." Tina Hassannia, Little White Lies

"Its modesty is immodest and feels wrong-headed. Part-pioneer bio-pic, part horror story, is this “entertainment”?" Armond White, CityArts

____________________________________________________________

Her

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 94%

"Its metaphors are more obvious than bricks...in the guise of being direct, the movie is actually maddeningly coy." Stephanie Zacharek, Village Voice

"Paper-thin whimsy...this one slices and dices your patience." Nigel Andrews, Financial Times

"Imagine a sappy, live-action follow-up to Wall-E...Her’s biggest shock is that Jonze loses his sense of funny; it’s unromantic yet is unacceptably sentimental." Armond White, CityArts

____________________________________________________________

American Hustle

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 93%

"There’s no heart under those polyester lapels, and what all that Aqua Net is pasting together is a few sparse strands of wispy story." Kyle Smith, New York Post

"...too vaudeville...the movie feels like a series of contrivances" Antonia Quirke, Financial Times

"It is all over the place, and the sense of improvisation that permeates the film feels like bad jazz riffs that wind up going nowhere." Lori Hoffman, Atlantic City Weekly

____________________________________________________________

Captain Phillips

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 93%

"Paul Greengrass' cinema-of-spasticity reaches new phony lows with Captain Phillips" Nick Shager, Village Voice

"Captain Phillips is less an adventure yarn about the daring rescue of a captured American than a celebration of a huge and expensive machine that crushes disorder." Andrew O'Hehir, Salon.com

"Captain Phillips is twisted, corrupt, lamely directed and finally, offensively simplistic." Armond White, CityArts

____________________________________________________________

Nebraska

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 92%

"...it feels downright disingenuous" A.A. Dowd, AV Club

"For the most part, I found Alexander Payne's American heartland drama, Nebraska, a rank exercise in hicksploitation sentimentalism." Keith Uhlich, Time Out New York

"These phony, lifeless stereotype performances are exactly the characterizations Payne’s fakery deserves." Armond White, CityArts

____________________________________________________________

Philomena

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 92%

"A witless bore about a ninny and a jerk having one of those dire, heavily staged, only-in-movies odd-couple road trips." Kyle Smith, New York Post

"...the experience still turns out to be fundamentally hollow." Josh Bell, Las Vegas Weekly

"...a story that, as the film proceeds, panders to audiences as if they were weak-minded, vulgar and ignorant." Armond White, CityArts

____________________________________________________________

The Wolf Of Wall Street

Rotten Tomatoes rating: 77%

"I couldn't buy it, and couldn't wait for the hollow spectacle to end." Joe Morgenstern, Wall Street Journal

"There's something missing from The Wolf of Wall Street, though...the film's relentlessness becomes monotonous." Michael Phillips, Chicago Tribune

"The Wolf of Wall Street is failed Scorsese...it’s still superficial bombast–sarcastic rather than funny" Armond White, CityArts

(Images: All Star, Rex Features)

Related

robot-and-frank-pic.jpg

The 10 best films you haven't seen on Netflix

heartbreak kid.jpg

The 10 worst movie holidays ever

all-the-kings-men-pic.jpg

Great cast, shame about the movie

daniel-craig-casino-royale.jpg

Casting choices fans hated (and then loved)

psycho-allstar.png

Good reviews for bad movies

alien.png

Bad reviews for good movies

Comments

More

Read this powerful statement from the foreign language Oscar nominees

It calls for worldwide unity and understanding

by Gary Ogden
27 Feb 2017

Everything you need to know about Mahershala Ali

Your one-stop guide to Hollywood's newest huge star

by Dave Fawbert
27 Feb 2017

The Best Picture gaffe wasn't the only Oscars mistake last night

Was this one even worse?

by Gary Ogden
27 Feb 2017

The Oscars just made probably the biggest cock up in their history

At least it was actually kind of interesting this year

by Gary Ogden
27 Feb 2017

You can watch the Best Documentary Oscar winner on iPlayer right now

What are you waiting for?

by Dave Fawbert
27 Feb 2017

The best dressed men at the 89th Academy Awards

This is the real quiz

by Sam Diss
27 Feb 2017

Ryan Gosling and Emma Stone's reactions to the Oscars screw up

They took the news in very different ways

by Alex Finnis
27 Feb 2017

Here are all the winners from the 2017 Oscars

Let's cut to the chase, who won what?

by Dave Fawbert
27 Feb 2017

Why Tom Hardy is the man the world needs right now

Politicians are lying to us. Brexit is dividing us. Donald Trump may be about to nuke us. But don’t worry, we’ve found a saviour

by Joe Ellison
24 Feb 2017

New Horror movie about racism is 100% on Rotten Tomatoes

Rave reviews all round

by Matt Tate
24 Feb 2017