Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

Casting choices fans hated (and then loved)

daniel-craig-casino-royale.jpg
heath-ledger-the-dark-knight.jpg
tobery-maguire-spiderman.jpg
jennifer-lawrence-hunger-games.jpg

Ben Affleck has been announced as the latest actor to play Batman, in Zack Snyder’s Batman-Superman mash-up, due in 2015.

As is routine in these matters, there has been much complaint about how Affleck is definitely wrong for Bruce Wayne and that is should definitely be someone else playing the role and nobody will ever watch Batman ever again, ever. So there.

It was ever thus and the casting choices that cause the most upset have a habit of becoming the most beloved.

(Images: All Star)

Heath Ledger – The Joker

Fans quickly forgot their ‘In Nolan we trust’ mantra when the director announced his decision to make Heath Ledger his Joker. Cue Brokeback Mountain gags as numerous as they were lame and poorly spelled complaints about how this would ruin Batman forever. Of course, Ledger’s performance, which he didn’t live to see, was not only the highlight of Nolan’s trilogy but the only performance in a superhero movie ever to win an Oscar. After that, suddenly everyone remembered thinking it was a good idea all along.

Anne Hathaway – Selina Kyle

Short memories, noisy Batman fans. Despite the whole Ledger farrago, their indignation rumbled up again when perennial good girl Anne Hathaway was given possession of the Catwoman suit in The Dark Knight Rises. The assumption was that Hathaway couldn’t possibly bring the requisite sexiness and sly humour that the Selina Kyle required. But as much as there are detractors of Nolan’s closing chapter, Hathaway’s success in flipping between fluttering innocent and cold-eyed killer was one on which most agreed. Except the permanently angry ones.

Daniel Craig – James Bond

Of all the reasons to discount an actor, hair colour is perhaps the most absurd. And yet, a large part of the negative campaign against the sixth 007 was the fact that his hair was blond. Never mind that Craig was the most accomplished actor to take on the part, those whose idea of Bond was still stuck somewhere in the winking camp of the late 60s would not be moved. Craig has since become not only the first Bond to be nominated for a BAFTA but also the star of the biggest film in the series’ history.

Michael Keaton – Batman

You can see the objection on this one. Keaton looks more like your typical Batman reader than a plausible Bruce Wayne. Not particularly handsome, not especially tall and not at all muscular, he seems much better suited to playing The Joker than Batman. Regardless of how opinion might have shifted on the Tim Burton Batman movies, Keaton was a hit. His was a quiet, intense Batman who seemed much happier behind the mask than exposed as his real self.

Robert Pattinson – Twilight

Twilight fans, at least the ones who like to make their feelings known on the internet, are on the higher end of the ‘Mad and Unreasonable’ scale. When Robert Pattinson was given the dubious honour of playing pouting vampire Edward Cullen they were absolutely furious that he was not sufficiently buff or mysterious to portray their fantasy boyfriend. The hormonally-fuelled screaming Pattinson has since experienced everywhere he goes proves that they quickly changed their mind. It was mainly the hair that did it.

[N.B. We couldn't actually find a clip of Pattinson being impressive in Twilight]

Jennifer Lawrence – The Hunger Games

There was some question among the more devoted fans of Suzanne Collins’ novels about whether blonde-haired, blue-eyed, athletic Kentuckian Jennifer Lawrence matched the character description of a dark-haired, olive-skinned, starving Katniss Everdene. Lawrence’s performance showed that she was perfect for the role. The film also had further attack from a small group who objected to the character Rue being played by a black actress, Amandla Stenberg, showing not only that there are people apparently incapable of reading the character description in the book, but that there will always be idiots.

Tobey Maguire – Spider-Man

Beyond anyone else on this list, Maguire really changed himself to become the character. There’s the argument that he was never really cocky enough to play the Peter Parker of the comics, but he undeniably possessed the nerdish aspects of Parker’s persona. What he didn’t have was a crime-fighting physique. But then months in the gym turned him into the buffest geek in the library, so much so that some fans complained he was now too big to play the wiry Parker. But most agreed he owned the role, and absolutely everyone was relieved that he got the job over the shortlisted Freddie Prinze Jr. and Chris Klein.

Related

original v remake.jpg

Original actors vs remake actors

garner-rex.jpg

Miss Marple and the worst movie miscasts

franrals.jpg

Actors And The Real Life Characters They've Played

Comments

More

This is what critics thought of Star Wars back in 1977

"...as exciting as last year's weather reports." by David Cornish

25 May 2016

The latest trailer for Independence Day: Resurgance will blow you away

"They like to get the landmarks"

24 May 2016

Space Jam 2, not Fast & Furious 10, next for director Justin Lin

23 May 2016

Idris Elba looks menacing in the new trailer for Star Trek Beyond

Aliens, spaceships, stuff blowing up - we're beyond excited. by David Cornish

23 May 2016

Michael Fassbender on superheroes, serial killers and shark memes

by Joe Ellison

20 May 2016

"I'll order you an Uber" - ShortList drinks gin with Patrick Stewart

ShortList’s Ralph Jones visits cult hero Sir Patrick Stewart at his LA home for an afternoon drink by Ralph Jones

19 May 2016

Daniel Craig turns down £68m to play Bond

by Joe Ellison

19 May 2016

Here's the brilliant new Lonely Island movie trailer

Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping gets second clip

19 May 2016

The second Ghostbusters trailer will restore your faith in the reboot

Slimer's back too

18 May 2016

A very important characters is finally returning for Rogue One

New leak on German website

18 May 2016