Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

All time FA Cup team

SP2.png

It's become all too obvious over the last three and a half years that we're quite keen on the occasional list here at ShortList. Alas, to our detriment, of the 1,568* lists we've made since day one, most have been entirely our own opinion. And we're usually wrong.

Props then to the ultimate FA Cup XI which was picked by tens thousands of football fans who are far better qualified than us to give their opinion.

The poll, ran by the fine people at ESPN Soccernet lists the 11 players above, with Sir Alex of Ferguson as manager, as the finest to ever grace the most romantic trophy competition in the world (bar the Lovers' Award).

In the poll Eric Cantona was hailed as the all time Dream FA Cup Player. Oddly, not Nottingham Forest's Lee Glover. With the third highest vote total, Ashley Cole’s FA Cup record of six Final wins has seen him selected in the Ultimate XI’s defence alongside Tony Adams, Bobby Moore and Gary Pallister. Ryan Giggs received the most total votes, and led an all-time FA Cup midfield where he was joined by Steven Gerrard, Patrick Vieira and Roy Keane. Fans selections up front was Ian Rush and Cantona, while Peter Schmeichel was selected as the all-time FA Cup goalkeeper.

Below is the names fans had to pick from. Let us know in the comments if you think the right decisions were made, or where you would have differed. Oh and keep the banter clean chaps. You're not shouting down a camera lens here...

Fans can watch exclusive interviews with some of the all-time XI in a one-hour special at midday on FA Cup Final Day, live on ESPN

'*'Source: Entirely made up figure

Photobucket

Related

football1.jpg

VIDEO: The Back-flip penalty

Comments

More

Jeremy Clarkson has died and been replaced with an imposter

What have you done with the real Clarkson?

by Dave Fawbert
25 Jul 2017

Linkin Park post poignant tribute to Chester Bennington

They have also changed their logo

by Dave Fawbert
25 Jul 2017

Why Danny Dyer's Deadliest Men proves he is the People's Louis Theroux

Don't let the memes fool you - Deadliest Men is a legitimately important documentary series

by Alex Timperley
24 Jul 2017

'Game of Thrones' hints at one of its most controversial fan theories

Not everyone loves this idea

by Alex Finnis
24 Jul 2017

The new 'Westworld' Season 2 trailer is very bleak and very violent

Dolores is on a rampage

24 Jul 2017

The meaning behind Arya's scene in this week's 'Game of Thrones'

It calls back all the way to Season 1

by Alex Finnis
24 Jul 2017

Check out the exclusive new trailer for 'Logan Lucky'

This is the summer's next big hit

by Gary Ogden
24 Jul 2017

What happened to Ivan Drago after 'Rocky IV'?

Stallone's teased he'll feature in 'Creed II, but what's he been up to?

by Carl Anka
24 Jul 2017

We have a winner in the shark vs human swimming race

Will it be fish or Phelps?

by Dave Fawbert
24 Jul 2017

We pinpointed the exact moment The Simpsons should have ended

Consider every episode after this null and void

by Tristan Cross
21 Jul 2017